FANDOM


  • Is it possible to make Discussions appear in the wiki activity so that mods don't have to patrol two sections?

      Loading editor
    • Nope. Discussions isn't MediaWiki, so can't be integrated into it. You can use the DiscussionsRC script, though.

        Loading editor
    • Well, Discussions info could be integrated, but they just didn't want to. Not that it would be easy.

        Loading editor
    • It should be tbh. Right now it seems like the two sections are different websites and this would help integrate them. If old forums and blogs can show up there why not discussions?

        Loading editor
    • Did you miss the part where I said "Discussions isn't MediaWiki"?

      Blogs are a MediaWiki hack. Old Forums are a MediaWiki hack. And that not easy integration of Discussions into RC would be another MediaWiki hack. Discussions are deliberately not another MediaWiki hack.

        Loading editor
    • Isn't everything changing to a new platform soon, anyway?

      With Discuss, forums, chat etc. all being retired and/or replaced?

      Thus, any changes to Discuss would be a moot point at this time anyway. 

        Loading editor
    • Discussions isn't going anywhere. Neither is Recent Changes.

        Loading editor
    • Only threaded discussion features have been confirmed to be retiring. Everything else is to be announced at a later date. In fact, they have yet to release information about the retirement of features other than Forum.

        Loading editor
    • Not being part of MediaWiki in no way excludes integration of Discussions data. It's all HTML in the end.

        Loading editor
    • Fandyllic, I totally agree with you. However, this particular discussion has already been had multiple times and I seems that we aren't going to be able to persuade FANDOM otherwise. I even tried giving them a starting point for getting wikitext in Discussions but they seem to have already made up their minds on that issue.

        Loading editor
    • That doesn't make what I said any less true. People need to understand that these are FANDOM choices and not necessarily technical barriers.

        Loading editor
    • It would however create a technical barrier, just like Forums and Blogs do now, that would obstruct later MW updates.

        Loading editor
    • It depends on your perspective. The way I see it, Discussions is secondary to MW. From that perspective, if something breaks because of MW upgrade, then either the integration needs to be fixed (as opposed to modifying MW) or dumped. They have already shown that they are willing to dispense with helpful features in exchange for MW upgrades. If the integration has to be dumped at some point, it would just be another one of the casualties.

        Loading editor
    • Creating a feature separate and not really integrated with MW was a choice and the problems with that choice are not a technical barrier. They may be a dev deficit in FANDOM, but that isn't a technical barrier. A technical barrier would be designing something that has an near impossible requirement, like needing a terabit bandwidth internet connection to be usable or something like proprietary digital right management that you don't have a library for.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.