FANDOM


  • I'm an admin on an online game wiki (w:c:rappelz).

    Lately, I decided to turn an infobox into a 'data-driven' one: all the data is in a lua table, and instead of just putting an infobox on the target page, I invoke the module that loads the data and produces the infobox on the spot.

    The basic model-view approach.

    The data is not subject to change often, and when it is subject, all the data should be reviewed, not only a couple of entries.

    While this will improve a lot the global look and feel of all the infoboxes that use this infrastructure (I can update all the data in one evening, all the text look alike, etc..), it also has a theoretical effect of turning down some potential editors who only use the visual editor because that's only what they know of.

    Has it been done before , how has it been received, is it possible to "train" the users and tell them "Hey, the visual editor will not work here, go to that page and edit the text between the quotes instead", are there other strategies for this (I guess I could write a bot script that would produce similar results...)?

    Thanks!

    -- Edit: As a side note, I have checked back and the infoboxes in questions have not been touched by me or another active user since at least 2015. We don't get a lot of "fly by edits".

      Loading editor
    • It’s definitely done before, for stats-heavy card and video games (like YGO and LoL, IIRC). These numbers won’t change, and are important to the game, so the wikis can’t afford missing an incidental edit to them. It’s complex and might confuse new users, but it’s for the greater good.

        Loading editor
    • If by YGO your mean Yu-Gi-Oh, then I believe you are mistaken. The Yu-Gi-Oh wiki doesn't use a database to fill the card templates. IIRC, the database is generated from the templates and then exported for use with YGQPRO (third-party online Yu-Gi-Oh deck building and playing platform).

        Loading editor
    • Andrewds1021 wrote: If by YGO your mean Yu-Gi-Oh, then I believe you are mistaken. The Yu-Gi-Oh wiki doesn't use a database to fill the card templates. IIRC, the database is generated from the templates and then exported for use with YGQPRO (third-party online Yu-Gi-Oh deck building and playing platform).

      My bad. At any rate, they use a secured method rather than direct input.

        Loading editor
    • I had a bigger, fleshed out post, but it vanished when I clicked 'reply'.

      Just to say: thanks for the pointers, it's really appreciated :)

        Loading editor
    • That has been happening to me and others as well.

        Loading editor
    • It happened to me before too. I guess I'll have to learn to copy my message before replying!

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.