Hey there! Please edit the title of your post and make it more specific, as is mentioned in our discussions guidelines. Titles such as 'Help' or 'I need help' give others no indication of what might be going on. Please make sure to read our discussions guidelines. Thanks!
Try to find the original image, turn it into an ICO using an online converter (Renaming it wouldn't work at all), and then try to upload it again to the ThemeDesigner