User blog comment:Shining-Armor/3 Ways to stay safe on Wikia/@comment-5558012-20150808030130

I would say the length of your password matters more for security than the characters you choose to use (the second one is more than twice the length of the first). The longer, the better. How I see it random is random, regardless of if you choose to use words or letters, numbers, symbols, and caps.

If I understand this comic correctly, if both have about the same characters (say 11 for the first and 12 for the second) there would be 28 vs 22 bits so the second would be easier to guess and less secure. With numbers, symbols, and caps the first is more secure with less characters overall. The only advantage to me appears that the second (with the same number of characters) would be easier to remember, but not necessarily more secure.