Forum:Wikia is plural of Wikia

I'm combining some comments from Talk:Featured Wikia and my talk page into one place below. Please add new thoughts on whether "Wikia" being the plural of "Wikia" is too much of a problem. Note that we don't own wikias.com, so using "Wikias" as a plural might lead to people using the wrong URL. Angela (talk) 09:58, 29 August 2006 (UTC)

Sometimes "Wikia" gets used as though it is the plural of wiki. But, AFAIK, Wikia is the organization that runs this agglomeration of wikis. I know that we have to differentiate Wikia wikis from the general run of the mill wikis out there on the Internet, but wouldn't it be better to say "Wikia wikis," or "Wikis on Wikia?" Reason I ask is that there seems to be considerable confusion. People have taken to calling wikis "wikia" and it is sometimes hard to figure out what's what. Adding to the confusion, is that we have headings such as "Featured Wikia" and "List of Wikia."

I propose that we rename these two pages as follows:


 * Featured Wikia --> Featured wikis on Wikia
 * List of Wikia --> List of Wikis on Wikia

Comments? Michael 20:10, 11 August 2006 (UTC)

Or we could rename this page "Featured wikis." It should be obvious that Wikia would feature Wikia wikis. Michael 17:55, 12 August 2006 (UTC)

To restate, in case the above wasn't clear: I think that we should differentiate between "Wikia" (an organization that hosts wikis) and "wiki" (a collaborative authoring medium used by a particular group). Michael 23:38, 12 August 2006 (UTC)


 * I agree with you. The company name recently changed from "Wikicities" to "Wikia", and when that happened, it was announced that "Wikia" was the name of the company, the name for an individual wiki, and the plural form as well. I find it confusing, and I tend to ignore it in common speech.


 * I would much prefer it if we referred to each wiki as a wiki. -- Danny (talk ) 19:02, 13 August 2006 (UTC)


 * Wikis on Wikia are called Wikia. I think this will start to make more sense in future when Wikia starts to offer more than a simple wiki, and the distinction between the two is more obvious. It also distinguishes between simply any wiki on a topic and the ones that are here. The wikis featured on this page are very much featured Wikia, not just featured wikis, since we only ever feature ones that are hosted on wikia.com. Angela (talk) 05:07, 14 August 2006 (UTC)

No question that they are Wikia wikis. But you seem to be saying that there are three meanings of the word "Wikia." If I understand correctly, we have:
 * Wikia - an organization that hosts Wikia
 * Wikia - the entities hosted by Wikia
 * Wikia - an individual Wikia on Wikia.

Thus one might say: "Each wikia is one of many wikia on Wikia." Have I got that right? Michael 05:56, 14 August 2006 (UTC)


 * One way of solving this lack of clarity would be to rename this page "Featured on Wikia." Thoughts? Michael 16:48, 23 August 2006 (UTC)

My concern is with the language. If we call individual Wikia wikis "Wikia," and also use expressions like "Featured Wikia" or "List of Wikia (plural), it seems to me that there will be three meanings of the word:


 * Wikia - an organization that hosts Wikia
 * Wikia - the entities hosted by Wikia
 * Wikia - an individual Wikia on Wikia.

The following sentence, I think illustrates the lack of clarity that will ensue:


 * I participate in a Wikia that is one of many Wikia on Wikia.

Do you see the problem? As an editor, I think there may other ways of ensuring that Wikia wikis are seen as unique and special. Michael 14:51, 15 August 2006 (UTC)


 * To be fair, you did strive for maximum ambiguity. Clarity:


 * Wikia - the company
 * wikia.com - the host
 * wikia - a Wikia wiki
 * wikia - plural wikia (use 'Wikia wikis' if you need clarity)
 * --Splarka (talk) 21:12, 15 August 2006 (UTC)


 * Strive for maximum ambiguity? Hardly. Rather my lack of skill in expressing myself clearly. However, I think you miss my point, which is that the word "wikia" is used in at least three different ways and that will be confusing to many. Michael 05:17, 16 August 2006 (UTC)


 * The only ambiguity is in wikia being its own plural. If it is the company, use "Wikia" or "Wikia-inc" (upper case, proper noun) and if it is the host use "wikia.com". --Splarka (talk) 01:47, 17 August 2006 (UTC)


 * Michael is right. It's also very annoying when translating to other languages. I say we change the plural form to wikias. Sure, it's not the propper Latin form, but last time I checked, Latin was still a dead language. Yeh, you still have those crazy clerics, but I don't think the church will mind.--Rataube 16:39, 16 August 2006 (UTC)


 * So that would be: "I participate in a wikia that is one of many wikias on Wikia." Still sounds strange to my ear... Michael 17:52, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

Here's a suggestion. Change pages such as "Featured Wikia" to "Featured on Wikia." That will make the Main Page consistent. I tried to do this, but was reverted immediately. People seem to be reluctant to discuss this, so I will leave it with this suggestion. Michael 15:10, 23 August 2006 (UTC)


 * It doesn't sound strange to me now, any more than it would sound strange to have a company selling bonsai called "Bonsai". And as we get better known, I think it will start to sound normal to other ears too.  The context generally tells you what the sentence means, although one with all three meanings will always sound a bit odd ("I went to Bonsai to buy a bonsai from their collection of bonsai") -- sannse (talk) 16:26, 31 August 2006 (UTC)