Adoption:Martial God Asura (2)

Adoption requests →

Please link to your username: https://martial-god-asura.fandom.com/wiki/User:RinsibleOne62

Please link to the wiki here: https://martial-god-asura.fandom.com/wiki/Main_Page

How many edits have you made on that wiki? As of writing, 430 edits.

Have you edited there each day for the past seven days?
 * If not, please do not submit this request.

Yes

How many days/months have you been editing there? Over 4 months

'''On the wiki you wish to adopt, please go to Special:ListAdmins. Then, list here the last time an admin edited and who it was.''' Prestomax, 31 July 2020.

Any other information: Apart from a handful of edits, Prestomax has been inactive for two months, has not responded to my enquiries about getting admin permissions, and we have no active bureaucrats either.

I have made a blog post regarding this adoption, and there are a number of fairly active contributors who (by lack of saying anything) don't seem to have a problem with it.

I will submit an updated form if in the following days if someone has an issue or similar.

RinsibleOne62 (talk) 09:32, August 17, 2020 (UTC)
 * Since you're waiting for more feedback in a discussion, I'm going to go ahead and slide you over to the right queue. This wiki is a bit closer to "anime" than "other", so they can make the final call.


 * I would point out, though, that you do have an active admin on the wiki, so the wiki isn't actually adoptable without their express permission. The adoption rules don't define admin activity by bureaucrats but by just regular admin.  So unless you have the specific permission of the active admin to adopt, you ordinarily can't adopt, even if you have some active users on your side. The reason for this is that it would be bypassing the most logical successor to bureaucrat rights: that other, active admin. After all, by becoming a bureaucrat, you would have the power to demote that active admin — and that's not really fair or respectful of their hard work over the years.


 * Also, you might want to consider whether the community silence you described is a function of their apathy or your lack of advertising. Have you specifically gone around to the Message Walls of all the recently active editors and given them a link to the discussion?  If you haven't, then you're not giving them a fair shake, either. People tend to respond better if they're invited, than if they're left to randomly discover a discussion.


 * Anyway, that's all just friendly advice. As I said, I'm transferring you over to the Anime Adoptions Team to let them help you out further.


 * 07:08: Wed 19 Aug 2020

Official Response
Dear RinsibleOne62,

As the leadership on the Martial God Asura wiki is active under our current definitions, I'm afraid I'm going to have to deny your adoption request. However, the anime team will strongly suggest to Prestomax that they expand the number of admins on this wiki. As you've been making terrific edits on this community for some time now, we will recommend that you be one of the first users that Prestomax promotes to a leadership role.

Thank you for submitting this request and I hope you have a great day.

Sincerely,

Lucas