Adoption:The New Macy's Parade Wikia (2)

Adoption requests →

What is your username? MickeyMouseLover2001

Please link to the wiki here: The New Macy's Parade Wikia

How many edits have you made on that wiki? 456

How many days/months have you been editing there? 10 Months

'''On the Special Pages → Special:ListAdmins when was the last time an admin edited, and who was it? ''' Luigitehplumber, last edited on Feburary 22, 2018

Any other information:
 * The topic of the Macy's Parade is a little bit of a special case.


 * For some reason, Fandom has an awful lot of wikis that, directly or indirectly, deal with the Macy's Parade. Given that the parade is an extremely specific, seasonal event, a proliferation of wikis about it means that we're splintering an already limited audience. Instead of letting yet another Macy's wiki just barely scrape by, I think the best thing to do is to try to bring the Macy's Parade fan community together. That way, you'll all get more people reading your work.


 * This particular wiki, though it has over 1K pages, is so unvisited that by rights it should be closed. It's been around since 2015, and it just hasn't caught anyone's eye. And I don't see how it will, given that the URL is one that's unlikely to be searched. I would strongly suggest that you start editing on w:c:macysthanksgiving, which is by far the healthiest, most visited community we have on the topic. It's the clearest, because it's what people expect the URL to be.  Indeed, when you search for "Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade" in our cross-wiki search, it's the only thing that comes up: https://www.fandom.com/?s=Macy%27s+thanksgiving+day+parade.  And when you search in your browser (as with Google) for "Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade" it's only that wiki that appears on page one of the results. If you search for "Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade Wiki", you get almost a whole page of results from w:c:macysthanksgiving.


 * That's clearly why it's got way more traffic than The New Macy's Parade Wiki, and I just don't see how you're gonna be able to overcome that advantage. So I can't, in good conscience, approve this adoption request. I've gotta urge you to instead join the main wiki.


 * 14:19: Wed 09 Oct 2019