Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25150955-20160909010405/@comment-1038387-20160912161421

AgentMuffin wrote: There are eight pages of base-level comments on the blog itself. That's plenty of feedback, much of which the staff have not responded to. In addition, many of those comments are replies, iterating on and debating the points raised in the base-level comments.

I believe there are twenty base-level comments to a page, so that's&hellip; over 140 people coming up with "actual feedback". And add two or more replies for most comments for the current total comment count of 502, most of which seems to be constructive, concrete feedback.

And were that not enough, you could also factor in the feedback being given on this thread. Yes, many posts are just signatures, but some of them explain their reasoning for choosing the option they did, or for signing the petition at all. There are 361 signatures; many of those are bound to be backed up with "actual feedback", whether on the thread or on the blog.

"It sucks", "make it optional" and the like don't count as feedback. There are valid points raised, but the number of editors that reply to a thread (or have someone else reply on a thread) does not add any value to the feedback.