Thread:Sannse/@comment-1705775-20120329120245/@comment-1699904-20120404221018

I'm glad we were able to get the guidelines reviewed; and the willingness to review the current guidelines does make sense.

However, I am concerned about the lack of gamer representation on your team. I've noticed that the community team consists primarily of enthusiasts and hobbyists. Of the team, only Trella could be said to represent the English speaking gaming community.

Modern games such as Modern Warfare, The Witcher, Dragon Age, Mass Effect, Assassin's Creed all some adult content - either in the form of combat, romance, or story line. As gamers, we play these games knowing that they are not the brightly lit, sunshine games of yesterday. We expect the games and wikis to be realistic, dirty and representative of the fantasy world they are in.

As such, it makes sense for '''Wikia to engage the gaming community in setting up this "global" maximum by asking for feedback from the gaming community. '''

Plus, in your post you pointed out that "it was complaints about images on Wikia that hadn't been moderated by their communities that started this clean-up drive.". And that sounds reasonable that if a Wiki is not moderated, then there is no local responsibility for the content and it falls upon Wikia to find a local moderator, to moderate that wiki, or to remove that Wiki.

In addition, I'd like to propose that Wikia let well moderated wikis set their standards by the games which they represent instead of using a "line in the sand" to compare wikis such as My Little Pony to those such as Dragon Age.