Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24794408-20140619064245

Because that little... because Pschycron deleted the thread, I'm hosting a backup here. Also I'm still banned on the wiki for "Treason" for asking the community's opinions of the current staff members.

http://supcom-fanon.wikia.com/wiki/Special:WikiActivity

http://supcom-fanon.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Rhianne_Burke/Calling_for_Community_Consensus_on_the_Current_Wiki_Staff

TO REHASH:

The Blog Post:

"Cruel as it sounds, admins pretty much have free reign. The best cause of action is start a blog to call for the community to give their opinion, and if there's a concensus against the admins, staff will remove their rights. Admins may not interfere with this discussion - they can give their opinion, but they're not allowed to remove part or all of it, protect it, or block people for participating in it. See also this - make sure to read all of it." ―Tupka217

Due to some recent issues involving the staff here, I thought it would be a good idea to get a community consensus on it. So, basically fill out this form here. (sorry I forgot about you Glitch!)

User:Slug gunner fan ◾Opinion of him: ◾Do you think he should stay B-Crat and Admin?

User:Pschycron ◾Opinion of him: ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff?

User:OrkMarine ◾Opinion of him: ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff?

User:$17 ◾Opinion of him: ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff?

User:Glitchrr36 ◾Opinion of him: ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff?

Please place your answers in the comments section below.

THE COMMENTS SO FAR:

Rhianne Burke:

User:Slug gunner fan ◾Opinion of him: His heart is in the right place but his methods tend to go badly after getting out of his control. He does seem to lack maturity at times (such as this incident about letting 17 take the full blame of something that ive been told about) but for the most part he's a nice guy who actually does care about the community as much as he does the wiki. ◾Do you think he should stay B-Crat and Admin? Yes. He's nice and stuff but I think theres a few things that he needs to work on.

User:Pschycron ◾Opinion of him: He's a bully through and through. Currently the only good he's done for the wiki is in the chat coding, and possibly with the theme coding (which isnt all that nice anymore). He's causing too much trouble and is too much of a bully and rulebreaker for any continued work he does to make keeping him here worthwhile. He knows how much damage he's doing here and he is gleeful about it. He's also been breaking rules, and giving bans for no legitimate reason, and is generally been abusing his power. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? Get rid of him. Never let him come back.

User:OrkMarine ◾Opinion of him: He's okay at being an admin sometimes, but for the rest of it he's a bit of a self-centered self-rightous arrogant dick who doesn't seem to care for the harm he's doing to the community and its people. He also isnt afraid to start harrassing people for things that are out of their control and is a bit of a bully. Judging by his actions, I don't think he's read the rules properly, as he was surprised at the rustling of jimmies being outlawed and I dont know if the alties are allowed for chat roleplay thing is confirmed, but he IP blocked Kleph for not having a page for 999 years without the chance to edit his own talk page. This makes no sense whatsoever, and Kleph may have been an altie that is sometimes used not as an altie (he does actually have an owner) but he was not used to avoid a ban. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? I dont know. Personally I dont think he's been acting with the professionality one should expect of an Admin. I know blocking Kleph wasnt an accident as the pages for chat bans and blockings are completely different.

User:$17 ◾Opinion of him: He's not very nice and has been harrassing me along with Ork and Psy over how Red brought the news of Basi's condition to the users of the wiki. ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? No. He doesn't exactly feel like a good choice of staff member.

User:Glitchrr36 ◾Opinion of him: He's nice. ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? Yes. He hasn't screwed up yet and continues to do his job well without causing unnecessary trouble.

5 hours ago by Rhianne Burke

Glitchrr36:

User:Slug gunner fan ◾Opinion of him: I think he is intrested in the well being of the wiki, but doesn't know exactly how to best accomplish it ◾Do you think he should stay B-Crat and Admin? Yes, but he should seek advice from admins on other wikis

User:Pschycron ◾Opinion of him: I don't like him. I may be biased as he used to use me as his guinea pig for chat coding, and he edits my pages to test things out without my permission. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? No. I think he should be demoted to regular user and made b-crat of a wiki made jsut so he can test things, then give an admin here the code for it.

User:OrkMarine ◾Opinion of him: I think he is a great admin and NCF policer, but can be a deplorable person at times. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? Yes, he should stay admin, but reigned in a little.

User:$17 ◾Opinion of him: I think he can be an ass, but he can be ok at times ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? Depends on how he acts for the next little while.

User:Glitchrr36 ◾Opinion of him: He is a great guy who doesn't get enough thanks for all that he does for this community ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? I think he should be made roll back at the very least, admin would be preferable, and b-crat if the powers that be are feeling generous. ◾NOTE: the part about me is a joke.

5 hours ago by Glitchrr36

ARMofORION:

User:Slug gunner fan ◾Opinion of him: Although he is a bit (read: Quite) biased, he has shown that he is more capable of doing administrative roles, if he isn't trying to flamebait people and isn't trying to cause stupid shit. He does actually follow rules to a better degree than the other admins. ◾Do you think he should stay B-Crat and Admin: Tenative yes.

User:Pschycron ◾Opinion of him: He's an ass. Plain and simple. He is rude, annoying, and pisses people off with very little care at all. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff: Resounding no. I'm not sure WHY he was put into Admin in the first place, especially with his history of pissing other users off.

User:OrkMarine ◾Opinion of him: I haven't been around him long enough to really make an opinion, only having heard things from others. From what I have seen on the various blogs and some chat entries, he is as bad as they make him out to be, but he is also one of the few that are bothered to admin the place. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff: Iffy. He is the founder here, but that gives him no excuse to break rules he and Slug made.

User:$17 ◾Opinion of him: Decent person, at first. Decended from there when he decided to make a rule just to have an excuse to ban me and Ace, and further harassing Rhi. Not sure what caused the change, but it was not a good change. ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff: No, unless he plans on calming down and getting his metaphorical 'shit' together. When he does, then I'll say 'yes.'

User:Glitchrr36 ◾Opinion of him: Friendly, good mannered. An-all-round nice person, but I am conflicted on his admin skills for the time being. He would be able to serve as an a middle-ground for arguments, of that much I am certain. ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff: Yes*

5 hours ago by ARMofORION

AOA1:

User:Slug gunner fan ◾Opinion of him: PITA (Pain In The Ass), but in a funny way. He's cool as long as you don't mention things he doesn't like; that's when he becomes uncool. ◾Do you think he should stay B-Crat and Admin? Though he can be a real pain sometimes, he definitely can manage a wiki well; my answer is yes. He should be more open to others' opinions, in my view.

User:Pschycron ◾Opinion of him: Self-admitted asshole; I'm not sure why, but he is. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? No current conclusion; he is an ass, but he doesn't seem to interfere with the rules. He only does coding, it seems. He thinks that he is above the rules, though. EDIT: He does appear to answer any question honestly regardless of relationship to the person or situation.

User:OrkMarine ◾Opinion of him: A real pain in the ass, but not a horrible person. He seems to freak out when someone doesn't like Doomguy for an unknown [to me] reason. ◾Do you think he should stay Admin and/or staff? Actually, yes; however, I think that he should really be more open to others' opinions. He can definitely manage a wiki or more.

User:$17 ◾Opinion of him: (avoiding the words I would like to use) Ork's apparent butt-buddy; also appears to just kick/ban people [if he can] when they disagree with him or try to explain something that he has misunderstood (to such misunderstanding is not necessarily his fault). ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? Fuck no; this is mostly because I can't let go of the fact that he is abusive of power and insults people as he pleases, but hates it when they do it to him. Unless he quits his bullshit, then my answer is firm.

User:Glitchrr36 ◾Opinion of him: I don't know; he seems friendly, and I've never had any problems with him at all. I don't fully know him, though. ◾Do you think he should stay Chatmod and/or staff? Yes; he appears to be nice and open to others. This is also due to the fact stated above: I've never had any actual problems with him.

1 hour ago by AOA1  