Thread:Brandon Rhea/@comment-5466786-20140920043241/@comment-26505747-20140920140941

Tupka217 wrote:

452 wrote: (Disclaimer: I have a "bias" against duplicate wikis.) We should form a club.

Whereas a "single game or movie in a series"-wiki isn't the worst, a "separate character" wiki has more problems than it solves, especially because it ignores a large part of a shared universe. How would you treat a page on Superman? Would you only cover his appearances in Supergirl comics? What about Batman? Batgirl? The Teen Titans? Krypto the Superdog? Tupka has presented an excellent point. In order to make a complete wiki regarding Supergirl, you would need to point out all her appereances and all the characters that over the years she has been involved with, as I am sure you know are many. With that said, that wouldn´t be a Supergirl Wiki, it would just be small DC Database more focused on one single character.