Thread:SeanWheeler/@comment-43707041-20200121215741/@comment-2054358-20200122010710

The original Arrowverse Wiki isn't merging series like Smallville because of continuity issues. So all your wiki can be if going by Arrow's continuity is a copy and pasted Arrowverse Wiki. And besides, the Arrowverse Wiki is still trying to figure out whether the characters on Earth-Prime are the revived people of Earth-1, Earth-38 and Earth-BL or are doppelgangers native to Earth-Prime, and your wiki is still small and your Oliver Queen (Earth-1: Pre-Crisis) is not nearly as long as Arrowverse's Oliver Queen page which is one of the pages they decided not to split for the Crisis even though that page creates server stress that makes it hard for me to scroll down. The DCEU doesn't even have an Earth number, so are you going to call them by the unofficial designation of "Barry Allen (Earth-DCEU: Pre-Crisis)?" Titans just had archived footage for both Earth-9 Pre-Crisis and Earth-9 Post-Crisis. Would that give you when in the Titans series the Crisis happened? Or did the Post-Crisis clips come from episodes before where the Pre-Crisis clips came from? They are merging with Birds of Prey because the Earth-203 scene didn't contradict anything from the show. You want to document comprehensive stuff around the Arrow multiverse's canon, just go to the Arrowverse Wiki. If you want to cover more DC live-action shows, don't be a second Arrowverse Wiki. Just cover every known live-action DC universe. You wouldn't be able to cover the shows referenced in Crisis very well if you stick to Arrow's canon. Smallville has it's own multiverse with an Earth-1 and Earth-2. Earth-167 from Crisis seems to be a copy of Smallville's Earth-1, but as the Smallville Wiki's page shows, had a lot of contradictions with Smallville's canon. So how are you going to handle Smallville? And for Stargirl, Arrowverse would merge her show when it has more evidence than a Crisis cameo to be a part of Earth-2. If that Earth-2 cameo ends up being non-canon to her show, then you wouldn't cover Stargirl. And besides, Green Lantern is Earth-12: Post-Crisis and Swamp Thing is Earth-19: Post-Crisis. Are you going to cover them?