User blog comment:Sannse/Your First Look at the New Wikia/@comment-3100721-20100818113540

The new Wikia skin appears at first great, but taking in what other users have stated, the fixed page width is a down turn assuming it is kept. It uses a social site scrolling toolbar, something I would rather not use. I would like to see the non-Javascript version in due time for compare/contrast. If possible, or already has not been done, please do not transfer Special:MyHome to the newest skin. Furthermore, I'd like to know if I can customize this as much as one could for Monaco, Monobook, etc. with the same or more freedom. For those wikis whom customized Monaco to the best of their abilities, I would hope that those customizations are portable from one skin to another with little or no changes (I'd like to see this come true).

However, while creating this other features are left dilapidated and broken. Such as this new (at least for me) commenting feature doesn't work well outside of Monaco, thus making any blog unbearable to read on Wikiaphone (which has more bugs than you can shake a stick at).

On another note, if possible, why not allow users to have the ability to set their preferences with those skins now and previously blacklisted under $wgSkipSkin in the LocalSetting.php file? It's not like it's going to hurt anyone, or would it?

That's all I have for now.