Forum:Why so many hub wikis?

I noted with some disappointment the creation of another Wikia hub wiki. Along with Entertainment and Gaming, that makes at least three separate wikis from Central for their individual hubs. Wikia (correctly, in my opinion) preaches the benefits of a more united community working together on a single project, but for some reason finds the need to split off hubs from time to time away from Central.

This is not beneficial to the overall Wikia hub navigation. Since the hubs now reside on separate wikis, it is more difficult to move from hub to hub. Users may not realise that they are now on a separate wiki, particularly because of all of these wikis now having an identical skin. This does not help users engage in the wider Wikia community.

It is also difficult for users who maintain hubs and try to keep them effective, looking good, and up to date. As a rule, it is always harder for someone to maintain a system if it is spread far-flung across multiple places. This results in unkempt hubs that often have dodgy information. Entertainment, for instance, has a hugely inflated list of wikis that simply is no longer effective. It also has a large number of directory pages that really are redundant and should have been deleted.

The general effect this also has is making Central less of a community hub than it should be. By splitting the community up into smaller sections, the potential of Central is greatly reduced. I would prefer that Central did not simply become a wiki wholly focused on support via forums and very little else. While support is certainly important, I believe that it does not fill out the whole ideal of what this wiki should be, and it does not fill out the meaning of its name - Community Central.

I urge that Wikia reconsider its continuation of making new wikis every time a hub of wikis becomes big enough. I instead advise that Wikia centralise more of its efforts in the name of community development. Wjxhuang, the 888th Avatar  {Talk} 10:49, February 24, 2010 (UTC)


 * 888Th Avatar, your concerns appear related to my earlier comment about hubs and central being broken, with Entertainment and Games and Sport now being the on three linked from the left menu bar along with Biggest Wikis . But the More link gets you to the Hubs Category which has 25 entries. !!


 * I would propose that some of the more specialist groups should be sub-hubs of one of a more limited number of true (main) Hub groups - all of which should be on the Left menu bar to help users find the smaller interest groups.


 * The Entertainment and Gaming sites appear to be being promoted heavily by wikia (obviously from biggest wikis these are popular sites) But they also appear to be easier to find than the more niche interest grouping and have the biggest numbers of editors. Hobbies appears to have been split into several other group, but was a natural heading like entertainment.


 * When i founded my wiki it did not fit in any real grouping to me so selected Hobbies as the most appropriate but it is also tied to several other groupings so I've added it to them to increase the chances of poeple finding it.


 * A related issu is what actual counts as a biggest wiki as there is no definition of what fits in the top 'featured' part of the page and i note it is growing steadily.


 * I agree moving them to separate sites appears to breaks the community up not unify it, a central way to navigate sites was logical - BulldozerD11 17:01, February 24, 2010 (UTC)