User blog comment:Sarah Manley/Sneak Peek at the New Look - Community Activity/@comment-824313-20100831023732

Wikia-- I like the new skin, I think the design is great, and a lot of the new ideas are brilliant. It's just not the right thing for a wiki. I still really prefer Monaco to this.

I know you won't change anything because of this comment, especially since what I've said about your judgment on Oasis in recent comments, but I still want to get my voice of mixed feelings out there.

Again, I like the design, the open feel (on your screen width, anyway,) and the wrapped-around banner effect, but it looks kinda too good to be true. The floating toolbar makes it FaceBook and the logo size is downright annoying. Unlike before, you have to roll over the edit links to figure out what they mean, and you'll end up using the "go back" a lot more, since I'll consistently confuse the site-wide banner with the wiki navigation.

Anyway, it looks nice. But like I said, not for a wiki.