User blog comment:Jenburton/An Update on Message Wall/@comment-3235402-20111005153238/@comment-13301-20111007182531

Piotr Bablok, if you can easily list things that Message Wall is A LOT better at that User Talk pages are, take a moment to put them on the forum where it's being discussed.

The message wall system is against the wiki spirit, per the reasons already posted. Since it's not completely editable nor you can't conveniently track all the changes made on it.

You seem to reiterate again and again that this new system is better, but you don't pay attention to the drawbacks, or justify them with side-effects workarounds, like the above message ( Old talk pages will be still visible (archived, read-only) )