Thread:Semanticdrifter/@comment-3474513-20131022100316/@comment-366087-20131022151825

Each wiki has its own rules and what sort and level of information they wish to present, and in what fashion. For example, The Disney Wiki writes its pages from the perspective of the real world, where the articles about shows are just that, about shows. While the Kim Possible Wiki, which focuses on one Disney show, writes its articles from an in-universe perspective, restricting the info which necessarily has to be from the Real World to certain sections (Notes, Trivia, Behind the Scenes, etc).

Neither are wrong, and in fact it can be good to have both views.

If a wiki wishes to focus on one medium of a franchise (animé OR manga OR etc), that is their prerogative, while the same is true of a wiki which might wish to embrace ALL the medium of the same franchise (animé AND manga AND etc). Neither are wrong.

Short answer, what is "over-contributions" or not is defined by each wiki.

Hope that helps!