Thread:Merrystar/@comment-23989026-20141021224924

I consider adoption requests as an application only requiring 2 contributions:


 * 1) a wikian who is volunteering to become an admin of the wiki


 * 1) yourself (or 1 of your Wikia colleagues) to process the offer

IMHO the only other contributions on an adoption request page should be relevant information to help you decide whether the adoption-offer meets the adoption guidelines:


 * other contributors of the wiki giving reasons to accept or reject the request


 * from non-contributors giving other information that you may need (eg: the applicant repeatedly vandals wikis)

IMHO the only reason JosephHawk is entitled to add to an adoption request page is to correct the application. But as shown with the Adoption:Ouran Highschool Host Club, he failed to read/research the request and gave his standard and inappropriate response.

I have just applied for another adoption. I consider adoptions as my way to recycle unloved wikis. As I am helping Wikia, I do not appreciate JosephHawk patronizing/condescending comment he has left on the request page. I feel humiliated as he is talking down to me as if I am a child and is commenting on my drawing! If you wish me to continue to make a constructive use of inactive wikis, please advise JosephHawk to use his time elsewhere. 