User blog comment:Brandon Rhea/Wiki Modernization Stage Two: Page and Article Headers/@comment-5558012-20170316205146

Eh, nothing exciting.


 * It appears like the wordmark background and the nav background are the same. That's a problem for wikis that have a theme dominated by a main color (I don't want to have to either redo my wordmark or come up with a different color for the nav).
 * Or is the background (wordmark and nav) an image based on a previous comment of an image being "uploadable via Theme Designer"?
 * Not a fan of using sitename as the header of the navigation (unnecessary duplication, I dislike the use of sitename - goes back to being unable to edit MediaWiki pages and no more being whitelisted).
 * Next problem, putting the Edit, Talk, Share buttons over the ad. That honestly makes no sense. Can we edit the ad?
 * Instead of a language dropdown, how about displaying the language flags?
 * The categories above the title seem awkward? Maybe it's just the use of "in:" that seems wrong (or perhaps it needs something else).
 * Finally, probably the biggest issue - even considering not to allow customization. One size does not fit all and this new header is no exception. At least from the screenshot, the navigation flow is going to be crowded and/or not support every wiki's needs. I, for one, don't like the huge headers (looks like the same size as the sitename - bad topography).

Okay, now to the questions:
 * What does the logged-in experience proposed look like?
 * What's under Explore?
 * Where is the Random page link, under Explore?