User blog comment:Shahid/Create your own Answers site/@comment-1281713-20100907163349

I disagree :-)

Such small answer sites are no different from the individual Forums on the respective wikis. What is the point of duplicating it and worst, taking away traffic from the respective forums? In particular if the answer site already has a hub, e.g. animanga

I feel the categorisation of the main Answer site is badly maintained, and if that aspect is improved, it will be even better that a collection of small answer sites.

I am waiting to see how many of these small answer sites will still be around in 1 year's time. True, they can grow if given time, but they can also die. And then the resources that the limited participants put in it, what happens to those precious resources then?

If what wikia central listed is correct, there are currently 490 editors on the main Answer site. I do not believe that a small site with a few editors can do a better job than the 490 editors over there. :-) Just my 2-cents