User blog comment:Gcheung28/New sharing options on Wikia/@comment-5252296-20150429022416/@comment-452-20150429131718

you really should consider pitching your ideas for us ahead of time so you can see if anyone wants the change, and more importantly if the community can suggest some changes before it goes live globally. I totally agree, and it doesn't make any sense why they don't.

The many comments specifically mention the fact that the buttons should be above the line - which should be obvious to anyone who has ever used Wikia - so, at the very least, this could have avoided by asking what we thought before going live with this "test".

The "test" part is largely the problem, because they've admitted that they haven't decided yet, so things like this make Wikia look like amateurs.