User blog comment:Dopp/Communicate Easily with Message Wall/@comment-3279487-20110926204244

Ok, wow, sure you got us again... and right after the new editor thing... well I'll try to post some "reasonable feedback" and suggestions: You probably got asked this so many times and responded as much, but can you explain to me what you gain to make a "not optional" update? Is a technical advantage? Because the standard tools are straight from MediaWiki, (right?) so you don't really have to work on them. Tell me if I'm wrong, because I'd really want to understand what you can gain by these updates. Okay, maybe this is my first reaction (I seriously doubt I'll change idea) but I don't like this. Well that's my opinion, now some suggestions and thoughts: Many other visitors exposed possible issues and I quote everything, but I also want to ask: what about subpages? I saw some users (me included) that use subpages for a specific topic, like bot requests for example. With message wall everything will be unordered (new suggestion: let us have the possibility to move a discussion up or down, or make section topic). I'm also concerned about how the "deletion" rights will be handled and if there will be a history of the comments.
 * About the "mandatory update"
 * About Message Wall
 * First I thank you for all the efforts you put in improving our editing experience, but don't assume that all you make will be appreciated by everyone, I mean everybody love to choose... would you like to go to a restaurant which has only a menù? Even if it's a good menù, it feels constrictive...
 * You said "how user talk pages have serious limitations" but since message wall won't be a wiki page, doesn't it make message wall much more limited? Because on message wall all you can done is to edit inside the "bubbles", like in a blog....
 * If you will go all the way with this, then please add a content part which belongs to the page's owner user, as the blogs have. This way we will have a little room for customization, because I like saying "Hi, this is my talk page" or doing other things like this.
 * The whole point to this update is to improve the talk page, the this is not the only way. What about creating tools for the talk pages? I don't know, maybe a tool which let you customize the appearance of the talk page, like a CSS tool, image going to your talk page and see a customized background, colorscheme or other thing... won't be really a personal talk page? Or other tools made especially for talk pages.
 * Some issues