Thread:Alex2424121/@comment-14250-20160810194015

Why did you delete w:c:Disney:Craig Gerber?

I was also planning on making a w:c:Disney:Craig disambiguation page:

Characters:
 * Craig Bean from Pepper Ann

People:
 * Craig Elliot, artist
 * Craig Gerber, creator of Sofia the First and Elena of Avalor
 * Craig McCracken, creater of Wander Over Yonder
 * Craig Nelson, voice actor
 * Craig Orion, voice actor

In reply to w:c:Disney:Thread:739402 since you disabled talk page replies for some reason...

1) I don't remember being told this before. I have a bad memory so I'm not saying this didn't happen but am wondering if you could tell me where because I couldn't find this on my message wall.

2) Why should only things mentioned on the show be included on the wiki? A lot of things not mentioned in Disney shows are included on the wiki, like when discussing actors it mentions other non-Disney works they've been in.

3) I never said Sofia was born in Freezenberg. That is merely the land her birth father Birk Balthazar hails from. The source makes it clear that she was born in Enchancia after Birk Balthazar and Miranda Cordova moved there.

4) You're not actually protecting the article's contents (I didn't remove any of them) you're protecting the article FROM content verified by Disney.

5) old news directly from Gerber and an official Disney spokeswoman. Episode 1 came out in 2012, it's "old" too by this logic, does that mean we discount it? Craig Gerber is the creator, you can't get a higher authority than this, it's more reliable than in-show statements since it's word-of-god from the show's maker. Characters on the show might be deceptive so taking their statements verbatim is original research.

6) what do you mean time and time again? This is the first I remember getting contacted. I remember adding it before and I guess it got reverted but nobody contacted me about it so I figured it was vandals who removed it who didn't check the sources.

7) Why are you so opposed to discussing the details of Sofia's heritage (her father's name, her mother's maiden name) when we know that Roland II is not her birth father? If they backpedal on this by introducing different details on the show I could understand siding with them, but they do not do any harm if they are the only details on this we have. 