Board Thread:Technical Updates/@comment-24006128-20200709172956/@comment-168424-20200714182022

92.255.137.33 wrote:

The accesskey attribute is missing from the "edit source" button (and others), but it's possible to write a browser userscript to restore it.

I know it's a lot, but I have some more UCP feedback. Mostly it's about features new to MW 1.33, or features useful (or critical) for developers or power users.


 * 1) The   tag does not work. (Test page)
 * 2) Modules do not have the debug console. (Test link; Gamepedia link to demonstrate expected behavior) This is a critical debug feature for module developers, and without it finding errors before saving changes would be much more difficult.
 * ,, and   Scribunto functions have no effect. (Test page; the messages should be somehow accessible for editors.) The log/logObject functions are also very important for developers. The addWarning function is more user-facing.
 * 1) The NewPP parser reports are unavailable without saving changes. (On Gamepedia, they are visible when previewing changes, allowing to measure the performance impact of page components without making potentially breaking changes.)

It's not impossible issue 1 is caused by the Oasis skin, and issues 2–4 are caused by the 2017 editor, but in particular 2 and 3 are severe enough that I don't believe it's appropriate to consider UCP production-ready without fixing them.

Also, I'm currently not logged in, and I know Fandom sometimes makes advanced functionality completely hidden from unregistered editors, so some of these issues may be solely because of that.
 * 1) So why would you expect the &lt;indicator&gt; tag to work? Did you read Help:HTML? You can't assume all HTML will work.
 * 2) Gamepedia is a totally different platform from UCP and you can't compare them.
 * 3) Until it is announce that Scributo on UCP has parity with something like Wikipedia, you can't expect everything to work the same.
 * 4) See #2.

Have you reviewed User:Noreplyz/UCP?