User:Noreplyz/UCP

The Unified Community Platform (UCP) is a new technology platform using an upgraded instance of MediaWiki, the software powering all wikis. For more information, see Help:Unified Community Platform and this support article.

Bugs
List of specific issues, errors or faults with the new platform.

Users

 * User Activity tab on Community Central shows something like cumulative total edits (global plus local to that wiki?) of user for each UCP wiki row.
 * Signatures are truncated to 256 characters
 * This is likely due to $wgMaxSigChars being left at the default value.
 * The user masthead is lazy loaded and causes jumping.
 * Changing the user masthead on UCP wikis won't refresh the cache on non-UCP wikis.
 * User pages aren't auto-created when you join a UCP wiki.
 * Some disabled accounts are incorrectly marked as non-existent on UCP. (zd#940019)
 * User mastheads often don't appear (screenshot).
 * When editing your profile masthead there is no "discard unsaved changes" button.
 * For at least one user (w:Thread:1880256), their avatar keeps wanting to change to an older one. This bug stretches across all Fandom wikis, including pre-UCP ones (does not seem to happen if avatar was set before UCP existed).
 * If a user is promoted to bureaucrat, it will always to show the "Bureaucrat" tag on the user's profile, even if they step down later.
 * The user masthead doesn't show the "My Favorite Wikis" list.
 * Wrong images show up after you left click an image and click to go to next in sequence in an article.
 * shows only recent activity.
 * No  for anonymous users, despite their activity logged on.

Editors

 * Adding a video to an article from the editor is not implemented.
 * Categories are not shown in Visual editor unless you go to Categories UI from menu.
 * Editing a section generated within a transclusion produces unexpected results. VE doesn't even properly support edit section yet. (ticket #932006)
 * Visiting a red link or non-existing page in a UCP site defaults with an "EDIT" button instead of "CREATE", which is pre-UCP behavior. (ticket #932146)
 * The gallery builder search feature for images on UCP migrated wikis return old images since over a year back or irrelevant results.
 * After migration, editing an article causes Infobox galleries not to be displayed. (both, Visual- and Source Editor). Workaround: purging the page may fix it for that page.
 * Some mobile browsers may have trouble editing in the UCP Desktop Mode Editor even with "add features and media" toolbar and "Describe what you changed" boxes doesn't have a Expand/Collapse button.
 * In addition, opening the mobile keyboard may cause the UCP editing area and the toolbars to incorrectly appear overlapped in some mobile browsers.

Visual Editor
 * Editing a page causes all data to disappear. The only accessible way to recover it is to use the source editor on the dropdown of the 'edit' button. (But can be then switched to visual mode without making it to disappear)
 * Interface color scheme doesn't adjust well for wiki color scheme. This can render portions of the UI nearly invisible to users.
 * Example: When editing a table in visual mode, two chevrons appear. One indicates the row and the other the column. To insert a new row/column, users must click the appropriate chevron (> or V). However, for wikis with light color themes, these arrows (above selected cell and to the left) are nearly invisible. This can trick users into thinking there is no way to insert new rows/columns. (w:Thread:1856782)
 * Users have reported problems in both dark and light themes. (w:Thread:1856782)

Source Editor
 * Source editor has issues where the text caret is displayed in the wrong position from the true caret, when there are over 1000 lines. w:Thread:1877174.
 * The preview feature glitches and shows the result of a missing blog page. The link to navigate back to editing is also not present. This causes loss of all content unless the user uses the browser's back button. (here)

Preferred editor See the entire behavior:
 * When on UCP, changing my preferred editor to "Source editor" (2010), changes my preferred editor to "VisualEditor" on Legacy wikis (and also disables "View source on threads"). When on Legacy wikis, changing my preferred editor to "Source editor" (Classic) (or enabling "View source on threads"), changes my preferred editor to "VisualEditor - source mode" (2017) on UCP. (ticket #976793)
 * This is on our list to fix - hopefully we'll be able to get this cleared up soon! Unfortunately, I don't have a workaround to suggestion.

Templates

 * The UCP VisualEditor doesn't support the preloadparams [X] url parameter. (w:Thread:1828522)
 * There seems to be an issue where the same infobox gets listed multiple times as an option in the editor's visual mode. It is not yet clear what triggers this. (w:Thread:1839523)
 * Template parameters inside infobox panels are not available in the graphical interface when adding the infobox to a page. (w:Thread:1840944)
 * Fortunately, I can confirm this is already on our list to review and fix, though I don't have an ETA for when the team can get to it.
 * If typed template as subpage (example: /something), it will use template /something instead Pagename/something

Files, images, and videos

 * The full range of copyright scenarios for image uploads does not display, making "This is my own work" the only option.
 * This may be inaccurate as the UCP  Licensing menu doesn't contain a choice "This is my own work" and many choices show up which are very close to the pre-UCP list, but none have the associated templates are created (unlike pre-UCP wikis). The closest choice to "This is my own work" that appears is "I created this image myself." which points to the   which is not created.
 * Videos in infoboxes: when a video is put in an infobox, the play icon is enlarged and moved down, nearly doubling the size of the infobox (screenshot). Workaround: adding a gallery in the page (outside the infobox), even if only one image, makes the video thumbnail inside the infobox display correctly.
 * Videos in galleries have messed-up images (screenshot).
 * Adding a YouTube video can fail when the description includes content blocked by the global spam filter. An error appears in the top background: "Fatal error: bit&#46;ly (Block #471260)"
 * Non-UCP wikis currently ignore the filter when adding the video, but that code to bypass it is missing from UCP wikis.
 * Adding a new YouTube video can cause black borders to be automatically placed in the video thumbnail.
 * OGG-Vorbis audio files do not show audio player UI and just give a link (wikitext example: ). See w:c:sin-city-diaries:File:Sin_City_Diaries_intro.ogg
 * You can see the audio player UI (and the audio will play), if you render as Preview while in the Source Editor.
 * Update: Ostensibly fixed. However, the player UI has another issue: it renders as a non-responsive white bar if it is embedded in collapsed content. (Ticket: #973822. For an example, click "Expand" in this article section and scroll to the Audio Box. Ticket submitted on September 13, 2020.)
 * Submitting a link to a YouTube video with an identical title as another will cause the pre-existing video to be replaced, even if it links to a different video. (ticket #931840)
 * Renaming/moving a video results in an error due to "new file extension does not match its type". (ticket #931840)
 * Moving (renaming) an image file page can cause the file itself to disappear. (ticket #932479)
 * Slider galleries in UCP display video thumbnails too low, not centered as pre-UCP sliders do. Image files appear to be centered correctly. (ticket #932643)
 * Links from images doesn't work, always links to   image URL.
 * Borders for images do not work. When adding a border such as, the border appears in the editing preview, but once the edit is published the border is not there.
 * Thumbnails in category Trending Pages previews sometimes show the wrong image (image in thumbnail is not on the page; w:Thread:1959144).
 * Uploading an image from Special:NewFiles, if MediaWiki:Licenses is empty, inserts  as the licensing template. This is almost certainly not a valid licensing template in practice. (ticket #968597)
 * Whenever a file is replaced with a new version, the new version's upload date shows up on the previous version.

Admin actions

 * Bureaucrats can't create Content Moderators and Rollbacks.
 * Bureaucrats can now properly promote users to the Content Moderator and Rollback positions.
 * Content Moderators, Discussions Moderators, and Rollbacks cannot demote themselves. Bot accounts also cannot remove that botflag from themselves.
 * Administrators cannot delete or move user pages, unless they manually insert  into the URL to delete the user pages, or change the URL to   to move the user pages.
 * Administrators cannot disable blog comments on blog articles. Users also cannot disable blog comments on blog articles that they created.
 * This has been mostly fixed by the new (disablecomments) permission, though non-administrators still cannot disable blog comments on blog articles that they created.
 * Bureaucrats may also fall victim to autoblocks if an abusive Bureaucrat revokes their Administrator flags and blocks them.
 * Administrators cannot edit user talk pages on wikis with message walls enabled. Any attempts to edit the user talk pages will redirect the Administrator to the message wall of the said user.
 * Users with the (deletedhistory) and (deletedtext) permissions can no longer view the deleted histories and their associated text for pages that they cannot undelete. For example, Administrators cannot view the histories of MediaWiki messages that they can't restore.

Special Pages

 * Special:Diff - Page exists but just doesn't work. It just takes the user to the landing page.
 * Special:Diff takes you to, which, unlike on the legacy Fandom platform, does not work. You would have to visit   for it to work. It's probably just a regression. (w:Thread:1860079)
 * Special:PermanentLink - Suspected similar issue to that for Special:Diff; definitely similar symptoms
 * The user list special page displays a lot of accounts who aren’t confirmed to have accounts on Fandom.
 * Special:ListUsers shows 0 members for most groups.
 * Special:ListUsers lists all users globally, rather than users who have edited on the wiki
 * Seems to be a new ListUsers page now, and no longer lists all users.
 * Special:MovePage - (Main) namespace not visible in list when trying to move a page from a non-(Main) namepace to the (Main) namespace. Workaround: select the Talk namespace, then move up one in the list to (Main). (ticket #933619)
 * The Sitename namespace does not support Visual Editor. Due to this, the edit button text also says "Edit Source" rather than the usual "Edit".

Local wiki header

 * Page count can become wrong due to bug (that may now be fixed) where moving a page would decrement the "Pages" count in the local wiki header. Compare "Pages" count with pages shown in Special:AllPages.
 * Renaming a page no longer reduces the page count by 1

Interface and design issues

 * When jumping to an anchor within a document, different than the currently viewed document, the anchored text starts beneath the Fandom bar and requires scrolling to actually see it. (ticket #933952)
 * On screens smaller than 768px the global navigation becomes unusable, with search, user dropdown, and notifications disappearing (screenshot – Release Highlights - March 11, 2020).
 * Special:Contributions looks much messier than it does on non-UCP wikis:
 * The fieldset in Special:Contributions (or "Activity") is not modernized.
 * The "Related Wiki" thing that shows up when using Special:Search is going off the edge of the page (screenshot).
 * Special:ListUsers has a very different interface (less options; drop menu rather than checkboxes and no filter by edit count) than legacy wikis.
 * When linking the first character on the line in the VisualEditor the little caret isn't positioned correctly (screenshot).
 * The toolbar is collapsed on every new wiki you enter.
 * There seems to be less room between paragraphs.
 * Profile editor on UCP interacts poorly with dark themes
 * is missing the oasis-dark-theme class on dark themed UCP wikis
 * Notification bell (for Discussions follows and likes) drop down has larger icons and text, but drop down rectangle is same size, so less entries are visible than previously.
 * A bug report has been filed. Whilst the icons are larger, this does not mean that less content fits within the box as reported.
 * Changing the border style for gallery images through Visual Editor does not work. By default, it is set to small, but it never updates when changed. https://prntscr.com/rw4az7
 * Adding the source   or   may accomplish what you want.
 * UCP Galleries sometimes inserts a timer class randomly that replaces gallery images captions. The page shows correctly for a couple of seconds but is replaced by JavaScript.
 * In the Admin Dashboard, when requested to "Upload Video" as a task, the interface displays a page which only allows image uploads. Uploading an image does not dismiss the task.
 * The save dialog contains a copyright notice. This notice links to a local page that is not created automatically and therefore shows as a redlink. (this thread)
 * If Theme designer is used to customize link colors to something other than what is provided by one of the default themes, only the colors of internal links are modified. External links and interwiki links do not obey the customization. This behavior doesn't occur in non-UCP sites. This is on the list of fixes to be implemented.
 * Temp files uploaded to preview in Theme designer are not flushed, even if changes are not committed with "Save, I'm Done". These files may appear as "Temp_file_(ten digit generated number).png". This is on the list of fixes to be implemented.
 * On some wikis, when the Search Bar is clicked, the text that says "Search SITENAME..." will not always display the sitename correctly. Example here.
 * The Latest Discussions area under Fan Feed (bottom of the page) does not show the author of the Discussions Post.
 * Hidden categories display as non-hidden in the list below the page, but are properly hidden in the list above the page. The preference to show/hide hidden categories does not affect the list below the page. (Zendesk #979231)

Global CSS Loading

 * The CSS for galleries is not always loaded. While this can be fixed by purging the impacted pages, it should load properly the first time.
 * The order in which the individual global CSS files are loaded is problematic. Styling for specific features use CSS rules with the same specificity as the general CSS rules. As such, which rules get applied depends on the order in which the files are loaded. In some cases, the feature-specific CSS is loaded before the general CSS. This results in those features not displaying as intended.
 * Entries for level 2 headers in the table of contents have both a number and a square bullet. At the time this entry was updated, the offending selector is ".mw-parser-output ul" and the selector that should be applied is ".toc ul".
 * Image collection tabs in non-Europa portable infoboxes don't display centered as intended. At the time this entry was written, the offending selectors are ".mw-parser-output ul", ".mw-content-ltr ul", and ".mw-content-rtl ul". The selector that should be applied is "ul.pi-image-collection-tabs". (Thread:1861732)
 * Level 2 headers have insufficient space between them and preceding content. At the time this entry was written, the offending selector is ".WikiaMainContent h2" and the selector that should be applied is ".mw-parser-output h2". (Thread:2016324)

Extensions/feature issues

 * The Recent Wiki Activity module shows UTC time only.
 * The Discussions activity feed doesn't work on UCP, it renders as plain text instead of creating the feed.
 * No "Founder" tag for founders.
 * UCP uses "Sysop" tag where legacy wikis used "Admin" tag.
 * Need to configure  to use AWB with UCP (w:Thread:1922264).
 * This is most likely intended behavior.
 * Starter Lua modules are created with an incorrect content type assigned to the pages. This prevents users from editing the modules as the editor detects this as an error.
 * Custom Achievement tracks from migrated wikis don't use the correct name in modules or the Leaderboard, even though the MediaWiki pages that store them do. (They use Edit Count track ones instead)

Media integration
 * Soundcloud tags don't work (from Help:Audio)
 * RSS feeds don't work
 * Facebook feed doesn't work (from Help:Social media integration)

Message Walls Mobile Skin
 * All links pointing to Message Wall:Username are redlinks since those pages don't seem to actually exist anymore.
 * Adding  causes the masthead and profile tabs to completely break (when on your user and activity pages) and nothing whatsoever to show up on your Message Wall page.
 * The Message Wall toggle in the AdminDashboard didn't immediately take effect
 * Bug report filed.
 * After the Message Wall feature is Off the Message Wall tab on the profile is gone but is not replaced with a User Talk tab like with what happens on non-UCP wikis.
 * Message wall notifications from UCP only appear on UCP wikis and do not appear on non-UCP wikis.
 * The "User talk" namespace no longer redirects to the "Message Wall" namespace.
 * Usernames above posts next to avatars on Message Walls do not link correctly. You would expect them to go to "User:USERNAME" but go to "User:USERNAMEUSERNAME"
 * Deletion of messages or threads has no effect.
 * Even previously deleted threads appeared back after the migration
 * Custom fonts are not working.
 * Duplicate header text sometimes. (w:Thread:1930299)

Notifications
 * The message in the notification dropdown puts a white line between the "X has written a message on your wall" (or whatevs) and the title of the post.[citation needed]
 * Reporting my own post on my message wall caused the notification icon to go haywire, and the mail icon disappears. (ticket #931103)
 * The notifications dropdown is absurdly wide.
 * Appears to be fixed, long titles are now truncated with an elispis instead of displaying their full length.

InfoboxBuilder
 * After following the flow to create an infobox (Press "New Page" button, input "Template:TemplateName", Select template type as "Infobox") you get taken to the Special:InfoboxBuilder/Template:TemplateName but the infobox builder never loads.
 * Bug report filed — thanks.
 * When modifying Section Headers the text explaining Collapsible Section Headers is duplicated (screenshot).
 * Bug report filed — thanks.

CSS
 * Personal global CSS requires use of a full URL and load.php
 * Due to how site CSS is loaded, does not work from Wikia.css
 * Syntax highlighter/checker recommends using HTML link tag instead. Apparently this is the case even on the legacy platform.
 * Importing custom sliders from the Dev Wiki doesn't work.
 * Importing custom sliders from the Dev Wiki doesn't work.

Menus
 * Changes to local navigation can take at least an hour to show up in the header (example of issue).
 * Changes to local navigation can take at least an hour to show up in the header (example of issue).

Blogs
 * Only admins are allowed to comment on blogs. The blog's author is also allowed to leave comments on their own blog.

Emails
 * Migrated UCP wikis are not sending emails when someone edits a page a user is following even if that's turned on. Though this is not happening to wikis that have always been UCP just migrated ones.

Inter-wiki links
 * Trying to use a URL with the beginning of the page name that matches an interwiki link (even if name uses accented characters, i.e. pok&eacute;mon: will match pokemon:) will remove that part of the page name and also will not allow a page to be renamed with that part at the beginning of the name. (w:Thread:1994102)

Problems regarding converted wikis

 * UNICODE characters, such as emojis and UNICODE-fonted characters, turn into question marks when the contents are converted from Special:Forums to Discussions (and supposedly on converted message walls and comments too)

Missing features
Some features that exist on non-UCP wikis are not currently available on the new platform, and are listed below.
 * Ace Editor
 * CodeEditor is dependent on the 2010 WikiEditor, which we are currently exploring to see if we can refactor into the 2017 Editor
 * Achievements
 * Coming soon, according to MisterWoodhouse.
 * Currently are available.
 * Creating new achievement tracks is not implemented.
 * Category Exhibition
 * Custom CSS
 * Global (from CC) and personal scripts and CSS are not imported.
 * Personal global CSS on the UCP is now available by editing a personal CSS page on ucp.fandom.com which is serving as a temporary Community Central style wiki for the UCP until CC can be transitioned at the end of Phase 1.
 * Classic Rich-Text Editor
 * FlaggedRevs
 * No status.
 * Message Wall Greeting
 * MultipleUpload
 * MultipleUpload has been added in the form of Fandom's custom in-editor UploadNewImages extension, but it doesn't support file renaming or setting file descriptions/upload summaries.
 * New Image Galleries
 * Semantic MediaWiki
 * In final acceptance testing.
 * Special:Templates
 * TabView
 * Welcome messages
 * Transition animation for collapsing elements.
 * Transition animation for collapsing elements.

Known changes
Some changes are not bugs but intentional changes, and are listed below.


 * Dev Wiki additions -- due to changes in class names and other functionality, some Dev Wiki modifications need to be updated to work with UCP while others may be obsolete. See DEV:UCP.
 * Localization strings have changed from custom Fandom translations built up over years on the forked 1.19 platform to the standard MediaWiki translations on 1.33, so some of the terms which non-EN users see will have changed.
 * The masthead doesn't include other details like location, birthday, occupation and gender. That's by design. We switched to a freeform bio with the Profile changes.
 * Special:WhatLinksHere does not work on Message Walls
 * Per our discussion earlier this week, that is not a bug. It is due to the new Message Wall design no longer being MediaWiki custom code.
 * Wikis are now based on a different 'Starter' wiki
 * The old starter wiki is NOT the source of new wiki spinup.
 * The starter for the new UCP communities is in a private database. It's not accessible by outside users. Shortly before feature releases for UCP, I will add any relevant additions that capitalize on newly available tools.
 * New Tags appear in Special:Contributions and Special:RecentChanges.
 * User tag text on user profiles is now in MediaWiki:user-activity-group-* and not whitelisted. Also, the User tag for "Blocked" is missing.

Removed features

 * Chat
 * Chat will not be ported to the Unified Community Platform.
 * Special:Insights
 * This maintenance tool that highlights unclassified templates, non-portable infoboxes and other maintenance issues on a wiki won't be available on the UCP, since it saw only little usage by communities on the Fandom legacy platform. These maintenance tasks can still be accessed through MediaWiki's special pages.
 * Shared Help
 * We're replacing those transcluded local Help pages with redirects to their Community Central sources.
 * Wiki Activity
 * No plans to re-implement in UCP. May try to change RecentChanges to meet similar needs.
 * Wiki Polls
 * Fandom's wiki-style Polls (AKA AjaxPolls) are not available on the UCP, and wikis that migrate to the UCP will not have this feature available. The global usage of the feature was not sufficient to merit the required effort for replicating the feature on the new software, given some rather tricky technical issues. Discussions has a built-in polls feature which can be used instead. For archiving poll data for historical reference, this Dev wiki script has been raised as useful.
 * Special:FilePath
 * Replaced by Special:Redirect/file