Forum:New Wikia Editor tracking post

This post is to track issues (bugs, dislikes, quirks, etc.) mentioned by users in the comments of User blog:Sarah Manley/Try the New Wikia Editor. I will start a list that anyone can edit, but I will try to keep it as updated as possible. -- Fandyllic (talk &middot; contr) 22 Jun 2011 11:55 AM Pacific


 * There are also comments at another blog post by Sarah Manley at Farmville wiki. -- Fandyllic (talk &middot; contr) 22 Jun 2011 10:30 PM Pacific


 * ...and the blog at Community Test wiki. -- Fandyllic (talk &middot; contr) 22 Jun 2011 10:41 PM Pacific


 * Quick note: I am aware of this list. I'm not sure if I'll edit it directly, but I'll certainly keep an eye on it and make sure we're working on the problems. 12:30, June 23, 2011 (UTC)
 * Building off what Kirkburn, we are watching this page and plan to do an update of all the feedback early next week once we are able to summarize all of the great input we have received. As for bug reports, we are investigating those listed, but will likely not be able to confirm/give update on everyone listed here. Thanks again and happy testing, --Sarah (help forum | blog) 16:38, June 23, 2011 (UTC)

Master list of New Wikia Editor issues
( ! ) ''Feel free to edit this list or add new items. If you want to re-organize it, add headers, etc. you can do that also.''

Issues preceded by are higher priority problems.

Issues/Problems

 * 1) Doesn't work with LayoutBuilder.
 * 2) No space at bottom between customizable toolbar.
 * 3) Button_comment1.png Could use an obvious Cancel button to exit editor without changes.
 * 4) Button_comment1.png No dropdown list or autocomplete for edit summary.
 * 5) Edit summaries are not remembered or used for autocomplete list like current/old editor (source and RTE?).
 * 6) Button_comment1.png Does not provide a preview of the edit summary &rarr; typos cannot be fixed and any links used cannot be checked.
 * 7) List of templates doesn't correspond to actual templates on wiki.
 * 8) * List appears to be hardcoded at MediaWiki:Editor-template-list.
 * 9) List of templates shown apparently limited to only 4 at a time (top of list?).
 * 10) Need to zoom out to see add more templates button.
 * 11) * Could be fixed with a scroll bar at the far right once window dimension exceeds screen size.
 * 12) No intuitive way to edit list of templates (if there even is a way).
 * 13) Adding categories pushes Templates area down off screen with no way to scroll sidebar to get to them.
 * 14) * Sidebar scroll bar eventually appears, but you may have to tab away and back.
 * 15) Wikitext shortcuts accessed from popup via small "More shortcuts" link at top rather than always visible.
 * 16) Preview drop menu could use a History link.
 * 17) Button_comment1.png Preview popup doesn't match real page width so may give a misleading layout preview.
 * 18) Slower than other editors?
 * 19) "Make new layout from this page" link under Templates area seems misplaced.
 * 20) Protected page notice only appears for admin level protection and over the top of the edit content area.
 * 21) * Not an issue in Source mode. Any protection notice activates the yellow warning bar; clicking on it brings up the full notice.
 * 22) Can't switch between visual and source modes like old RTE.
 * 23) * If “enable RTE” is ticked in Special:Preferences, you can switch between modes. If unticked, than you cannot switch between modes: There will be no Visual mode tab.
 * 24) Button_comment1.png MediaWiki:Copyrightwarning not visible.
 * 25) No access to wiki menus (that normally appear to right of wordmark).
 * 26) Button_comment1.png In visual mode, copying and pasting section headers does strange things. Sometimes it won't paste, but it screws up a following section. Sometimes it pastes.
 * 27) Templates with HTML that should change page flow (like  ) are not honored in visual mode.
 * 28) In visual mode, some text in popups for template (puzzle piece) and HTML comment (note icon) is light gray on white, so very hard to read.
 * 29) Can't get to old source editor when New Wikia Editor is enabled on a wiki.
 * 30) Button_comment1.png No "Follow this page" checkbox.
 * 31) Source mode editing font size is too big.
 * 32) * Font is now smaller, but still has unnecessarily heavy font-weight.
 * 33) Display problems at top of screen with long wordmark names or page titles.
 * 34) If you go to a redirect page, the target page displays, but when you hit Edit, it tries to edit the page with the redirect.
 * 35) * Appears to be fixed.
 * 36) Added dependencies (AJAX, JS, Lightbox, etc.) on source-only mode (RTE off) that make it slower and less scrollability.
 * 37) Button_comment1.png LinkSuggest and TemplateSuggest (?) can make editor slow down to a snail’s pace in source-only mode (RTE off).
 * 38) Directional arrow keys do not work with LinkSuggest and TemplateSuggest (?) the way they currently do with current RTE and Monobook editor. Must use mouse to make selection.
 * 39) Button_comment1.png Can't edit at all with JS disabled.
 * 40) You still get 2 scroll bars if your page contents are more than a screen height high and your sidebar has to scroll for more categories and templates.
 * 41) Button_comment1.png Need an option in preferences when RTE enabled to make source mode the default.
 * 42) Button_comment1.png In source mode with wide screen enabled, lots of the edit area is not clickable and the scroll bar for the edit area seems to be broken and doesn't respond to clicks.
 * 43) "Follow pages I edit" preference may get reset to turned on.
 * 44) * Appears to be fixed.
 * 45) Button_comment1.png The new editor doesn't work well in Opera browser.
 * 46) Hard to discover option to either enable or disable blog commenting.
 * 47) Hover over the Publish button, it looks pressed.
 * 48) Source font has display problems (some letter look bold, some do not) which may be based on picking an awkward font size.
 * 49) * Is this fixed?
 * 50) Button_comment1.png In preview, slider galleries cannot be viewed, making it difficult to figure out whether the text will fit in the space available.
 * 51) When creating a new blog, blog title as unnecessary colon like: "User blog:Fandyllic/:Test blog"
 * 52) System message popups (protected page, etc.) need to support scrolling if the message is multiple lines.
 * 53) Add Publish/Save button and Preview button to Show changes popup.
 * 54) Add Publish/Save button and View changes button to Preview popup.
 * 55) Preview does not allow Ctrl-clicking of links to open the link in a new tab (the default action in most browsers). However, right-clicking them does bring up a menu that allows you to choose this option.
 * 56) * On Mac OS X, ctrl-click is equivalent to right-click (legacy of single-button mouse days), so this may be a Windows only issue or a browser specific issue.
 * 57) Keyboard shortcuts for "View changes" (Alt-v) and for "Preview" (Alt-p) do not work.
 * 58) No way to add or edit the edit summary in preview mode, but since there is a "Publish" button, you can easily submit a change without an edit summary.
 * 59) Visual mode appears to add a carriage return to source after any HTML comments.
 * 60) Preview (or the sidebar) doesn't show categories, if they are only added by templates.


 * Minor
 * 1) Missing CategorySelect at bottom, but an equivalent is now in sidebar.
 * 2) Preview button on side rather than bottom that most users were used to.
 * 3) Quirky display issues when switching between visual and source mode.
 * 4) Old button bar at top of source mode could be redone to match new look.
 * 5) Return characters at the end of a page are truncated.
 * 6) GeSHi extension not working in Preview. Works in current RTE and Monobook.
 * 7) Preferences or cookies to 'remember' your settings of the modules on the right side. It would be nice to keep them minimized if they aren't used as often. Same with fullscreen/module bar.
 * 8) Preview 'button' doesn't look like a button. It should be classed with .wikia-button so users know to click it rather than it simply looking like a drop-down box.

Suggestions

 * 1) Move sidebar down a bit so top bar can be widened.
 * 2) Resizable preview popup window. Not all wikis have the same fixed width.
 * 3) Need an easy way to add HTML comments  in Visual mode.

Comments
The list is getting pretty big. I wonder how many issues they will address before they stop calling it Beta. -- Fandyllic (talk &middot; contr) 22 Jun 2011 1:53 PM Pacific