User blog comment:Brandon Rhea/Wiki Modernization Stage Two: Page and Article Headers/@comment-25034963-20170316212249

SAD! NO GOOD, VERY BAD, LOW ENERGY!!

Trump-isms aside, I really do hate this layout. Honestly, I realize wikia needs to support communities other than those similar to our, and I can think of some communities that might want this layout, but it might be good to make it optional wiki-by-wiki, no?
 * No chat tab. Chat is great, and it's probably better if the tab for it is front and center, even opening drop-down menu would make it much harder for new users to find.
 * The Edit, share, and talk buttons are over an ad. Weird choice, makes users less likely to look for them (assuming they're sane and avert their attention from ads). And if you need a greedy reason, looking at it from your perspective, it seems to just makes people more likely to use adblock.
 * Everyone has to design their banners to work with it. Furthermore, it's way more crowded than the current layout, less visually appealing, though that does somewhat come down to personal taste.