Admin Forum:Indefinite Ban Issue

I am currently dealing with an issue involving a previous member who decided to leave Wikia and join the Curse variant of our wiki. This was fine and accepted until he came back and made the attempt to convince another of our users to leave for the Curse variant as well. While this other user made his own decision on leaving, I took it upon myself to give the one advertising Curse an indefinite ban in response. (This judgment was also cast after taking his previous ban history into account.) I am receiving a little opposition on this manner, and so I was wondering if there are any policies or ToU/ToA that would help settle this dispute, or if I shouldn't take this recent action into consideration at all. I'd appreciate any constructive information. Thank you for reading.  Skål! 22:50, May 10, 2012 (UTC)


 * The Wikia Terms of Use forbid editors from using Wikia to "post, upload, transmit, share, or store unsolicited or unauthorized advertising, solicitations, "spam", or any other type of unauthorized solicitation."
 * You could choose to interpret this member's actions as advertising, but from the little you have mentioned and that I have seen of the situation, I probably wouldn't agree with that label. Leaving messages on many editors' talk pages just to plug www.falloutwiki.com would be advertising, but speaking to an acquaintance and personally advocating a service that you like is not advertising. For instance, say you happen to be visiting a local movie theater with your friends, and while you are there you gush to them about why you like a different movie theater in town much better. That's not advertising: it's freedom of speech.
 * If the member you mention continued by trying to convince many other editors with whom he was not acquainted, that would be a different matter.
 * In your discussion with the banned individuals at Nukapedia (Broccoli. & Gauzz Rifle) you also mention that they posted "slanderous" remarks about Nukapedia on their Fallout Wiki user pages (example). Personally, I would never consider that grounds for banning on the wiki where I am admin. But really, the appropriate response (to ban or not to ban) should depend on the existing policies at Nukapedia (Administration policy, User conduct guideline). I don't see anything on the Nukapedia policy pages to support these ban reasons. --Gardimuer { ʈalk } 02:11, May 11, 2012 (UTC)