User:Anno1404/Dead Rising dispute

As you read this, please keep one question in mind:

Is User:Ash Crimson and User:Frank-West's behavior that of what is expected of an Administrator and Bureaucrat?

{| class="wikitable collapsible collapsed" !align="left" width="700"|

My experience on deadrising.wikia.com
I had over 1,000 edits on deadrising.wikia.com. I returned to editing dead-rising.wikia.com because after studying User:Ash Crimson's edit history, particularly how he treats founder User:Wikiar, the way Ash Crimson treats new editors, and how Ash Crimson desysops any admin who does not edit once a week, I felt like deadrising.wikia.com was the wrong wikia for me.

In response to starting to edit dead-rising.wikia.com again, Ash Crimson told me to "fuck off", that I was a "douche", "scrub" (edit differences below) and indefinitely blocked me.
 * }

History
{| class="wikitable collapsible collapsed" !align="left" width="700"|

How Ash Crimson became an bureaucrat, interaction before this week
User:Wikiar was originally the only administrator and bureaucrat on deadrising.wikia.com.

On November 30, 2009 User:Ash Crimson requested adoption rights. In the community discussion, only one person responded, suggesting Ash Crimson ask the founder (Wikiar) for admin rights. Ash Crimson did not.
 * User:Ash Crimson requests to be an admin

On 08:08, February 27, 2010 User:Ash Crimson requested adoption again, writing:
 * "The current Admin rarely signs on and he never listens to anything users have to say. I've tried communicating with him but he ignores me." User Ash Crimson was given administrator rights on March 5, 2010.

On 20:54, April 30, 2010 Ash Crimson wrote this note to four active editors. She did not discuss this change with fellow bureaucrat Wikiar or anyone else before:
 * User Ash Crimson unilaterally makes a one week rule
 * I'm making a new rule for admins. If an admin doesn't edit at all/a lot for a week, he/she will lose their admin status.

On May 21 2010, User:Ash Crimson said to User:Frank-West
 * User Ash Crimson pushes to have Wikiar step down
 * " As soon as I got admin status, he decides it's time to start editing again =\ (not often though) I can't remove his bureaucrat status (unfortunately).. if I could he wouldn't be an admin any more. You could try sending a message to central wikia asking for his status to be removed, but I don't think that would work =[Anyways, I wish you could see how awful this place looked like 3 months ago (due to poor management >,>).. lol User_talk:Frank-West. 00:08, May 21, 2010

That day User:Frank-West asked User:Wikiar step down as bureaucrat.
 * Do you have ownership of this wiki? If you do, I kindly request that you hand it over to Ash, because frankly, you hardly ever do anything here. This place was a wreck before Ash showed up because you had abandoned it. I think that Ash is definitely the rightful owner now, if you would only let him be.

User:Frank-West and User:Ash Crimson continued to ask User:Wikiar to step down.
 * }

{| class="wikitable collapsible collapsed" !align="left" width="700"|

June 18 - 20, 2010 Ash Crimson unblocking a severe personal attack editor
On June 18, 2010, User:Ash Crimson deleted User:Wikiar's talk page.User talk:Wikiar/Archive: Forum: Adminship Starting a Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Wheel War.

User:Ash Crimson stated that User:Wikiar was "immature", a "spiteful vandal", a "horrible admin",  and to "grow up". (edit diffs in section).

On the same day, User:Karensarahrocks wrote to User:Wikiar:
 * "you should think about being alittle more helpful instead of being a dick sucking little bitchface all the fucking time. so while your fucking you star wars action figures ash was giving a damn about this wiki, the wiki you left." (emphasis my own).

User:Karensarahrocks was blocked three times since May 23 by User:Frank-West for insulting other editors.

User:Wikiar blocked User:Karensarahrocks"with an expiry time of 3 months", "User was warned to not send insulting messages." 

User:Ash Crimson then reduced the block to 2 hours. "User was warned to not send insulting messages."

User:Wikiar wrote a warning on User:Karensarahrocks's talk page. User:Ash Crimson then reverts the warning, starting an edit war.

User:Ash Crimson begins to block User:Wikiar,  creating another Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Wheel War
 * }

User:Ash Crimson reports User:Wikiar to User talk:Sarah Manley at community.wikia.com.

Personal attacks
The continued personal attacks are ONLY from Ash Crimson, Frank-West, and their supporters. Ash Crimson supported User: Karensarahrocks's severe personal attacks against Wikiar by repeatedly removing Wikiar's warning to Karensarahrocks.

Ash Crimson's personal attacks
emphasis my own


 * 1) To User:Anno1404 Fuck off. User_talk:Ash_Crimson 16:35, June 11, 2010 (edit deleted)
 * RE: User:Anno1404. I'm not going to remove his images simply because he's a douche. User_talk:The_Yoshiman_97 17:31, June 17, 2010.
 * RE: User: Wikiar You gonna help? Write to the central wikia. Wikiar needs to be removed from this site for good.. He's a spiteful vandal. (Canvassing User_talk:Frank-West to help remove Wikiar). 22:59, June 18, 2010
 * RE: User:Wikiar You ignored it because your a horrible admin. User_talk:Wikiar. 21:01, June 18, 2010.
 * RE: User:Anno1404 "Our wiki is 100x better than that scrub's wiki." User_talk:Frank-West 10:10, June 12, 2010
 * RE: User:Anno1404 I don't care what Anno does. He can go fuck himself for all I care. .. excuse me =\ User_talk:Frank-West 16:36, June 11, 2010
 * RE: User:Anno1404 "You think they'd close down the one that scrub is currently editing?"User_talk:Mistertrouble189 07:19, June 11, 2010
 * To: User:MagcargoMan Edit: looks like I was right.. you are a creep. lol User_talk:MagcargoMan 02:34, May 22, 2010.
 * RE: User:Wikiar: "you're immature" 13:10, June 18, 2010. User talk:Wikiar
 * RE: User:Anno1404 I don't think he's really in his 30s.. way too immature. User_talk:The_Yoshiman_97 17:20, June 17, 2010
 * RE: User:Wikiar grow up User talk:Karensarahrocks 23:21, June 18, 2010.
 * 1) To User:Anno1404 .. you sure are immature. Anyway, have fun with your fail whale wiki. I'll be removing all of your worthless edits from our wiki. User talk: Anno1404 07:28, June 11, 2010. (deleted edit, restored on request)
 * RE: User:MagcargoMan I'd say sorry.. but I'm not. You've really been coming off as creepy lately. User_talk:MagcargoMan. 02:02, May 22, 2010
 * RE: User:Wikiar: Anyways, I wish you could see how awful this place looked like 3 months ago User:Frank-West 00:08, May 21, 2010 (due to poor management >,>)
 * RE: User:Anno1404 "I believe he quit this wiki because he didn't get his way with the template. That kind of attitude will kill a wiki... sounds familiar *cough* wikiar."  (Reverted portion of text in next edit)

Ash Crimson removes other editors edits, because from particular editor

 * To User:The_Yoshiman_97: I think the biggest reason I removed it was because Anno did that.. and I hate him. User_talk:The_Yoshiman_97 17:05, June 17, 2010.

Personal attacks
emphasis my own
 * "you should think about being alittle more helpful instead of being a dick sucking little bitchface all the fucking time. so while your fucking you star wars action figures ash was giving a damn about this wiki, the wiki you left." User_talk:Wikiar 22:22, June 18, 2010.

Personal attacks
emphasis my own


 * 1)  To User:Anno1404:  You can stay here and keep this wiki, you traitor. It's not like this one will ever ammount to anything. And with that I say fuck you and good bye. User talk:Anno1404 15:17, June 11, 2010  (deleted, comment restored on request)
 * 2) RE User:Anno1404:  " What a Bastard" User_talk:The_Yoshiman_97 19:39, June 10, 2010
 * 3)  Changing User:Anno1404 words:  as I am a traitor and deserved any insults that came to me. User talk: Frank-West  (deleted, comment restored on request)
 * 4) Y'know you're gonna have to block me if you want this to stay gone. Go to the REAL WIKI! It's better than this garbage! Anno is a traitor and he's lying to you! Talk:Dead Rising Wiki. 15:24, June 11, 2010   (deleted, comment restored on request)
 * 5) On User:Anno1404: My name is Anno and I am a traitor. Go to the real wiki instead of what I made here. 15:26, June 11, 2010.
 * 6) To User:Anno1404: That was a constructive edit, traitor. User talk:Anno1404 01:48, June 11, 2010. (deleted, comment restored on request)

More of User:Frank-West's personal attacks can be found and added if necessary.

Conclusion and suggestions
It is with a heavy heart that I post this today. I think we would all would much rather be building wikias then commenting on editor behavior. It is not my intent to reignite the tempers which flared on these two wikis. Instead, I post this here because I feel what fueled this fire was personal attacks which do nothing to serve the goals of wikia.

Because of their continued personal attacks, wheel warring, etc. I suggest that User:Ash Crimson and User:Frank-West either:
 * 1) Be admonished that such personal attacks (and in Ash Crimson's case severe wheel warring) are not acceptable on Wikia, and that further attacks could result in being blocked or losing administrative privileges.
 * 2) Probation for both User:Ash Crimson and User:Frank-West, or mentorship, allowing aggrieved editors to go to a certain Community Central administrator if such behavior continues.
 * 3) Desysop both User:Ash Crimson and User:Frank-West