User blog comment:Rupert Giles/Prototype for a new article layout/@comment-3328029-20141212071409

I actually like your thinking on this, if not some of the execution. I don't understand why there needs to be so much padding on the left and right of the content. I also hate some of the ads that the go in the content, I almost prefer having the rail simply to prevent this. I love the new ToC (as well as it following you, I can finally stop using CSS to make this happen), I love/hate the new edit button, and while I understand it and think I'll like it in the long run, I'll miss having the "settings" on the bar at the bottom of the screen.

I DON'T like the new h1 page titles (so much needless whitespace!), and find the new global nav... kind of odd. I like that it seems less busy, but kinda miss not having to hover over something to see links (but I think I'll like this change in the long run; although, again, so much whitespace '~')

So to recap; please stop adding so much useless whitespace, it makes me cry ;_; And I'm not sure why you had to up the font size again, you guys must really hate nice compact layouts that don't involve lots of needless scrolling.

Also, I would love if the new siderail was "collapsible", and was remembered between page (much like how current ToCs remember your preference).

Edit: You should also consider making the edit "hover button" an actual edit link as well.