Thread:Unok/@comment-11842624-20141018160754/@comment-3544775-20141019000205

1) Ok, so now you understood what I was trying to say. It's kind of funny, fluid layout was rolled in to utilize better the space for widescreen monitors, but now they suffer this XD Don't know about solution, it's get better when I minimize my browser, everything gets far more compact and take less space with better quality images. But that basically means I'm disgracing my widescreen and makes the fluid layout pointless. If there is not a limit of 4 images per line, things can work better. This is why I say the old gallery was better, because it have additional functions, it also have issues too, but comparing them for me the old one wins. It would be great if you can use both galleries when you want, so those who want would be able to use the new, and those who don't to use the old one. But my fears are the old gallery will eventually disappear.

2) Exactly what I was trying to imply and why the squares can't do it either and that's why most wikis don't use squares. It's up to people to decide what they like more: original shape or square, but the new gallery don't give you that choice, this is what I don't like. The current gallery is universal, what wikia can do is fix a little it's space between images. I mean, spacing="small" can almost do the same space as the new gallery (for squares or widescreen images). As far I knew the gallery is based on table, so that's why you end up with larger empty spaces on images different than squares and solution becomes quite hard.

You mean there will be a discussion of making the new gallery the only gallery? I wouldn't mind the new gallery if there is: That's basically what the old one have, and what the new one don't have...
 * choice of format: landscape, portrait, squares, original shape, etc.
 * more than 4 images per line: ofc when possible, so that widescreen users to not get upscaled images that take more space.
 * thumb size control, because 240x240 can be too large for some people tastes.