User blog comment:Poseidon133/Why do some wikis have talk pages?/@comment-1038387-20150415102423/@comment-252417-20150415124752

Yeah, I definitely agree with Tup. In the beginning, it was even worse, because comments was include in the navigation box, which detracted even more from the page, and was an unnecessary addition. I had to turn it off on Yogi Bear Wiki, as it just looked terrible. Beyond terrible.

I do, however, wish that talk pages were more like message walls. Obviously, talk pages can get messy at times, and sometimes a lot. Also, I don't always know what to give my header name, and sometimes it's quicker just not to give one, but it would definitely help by automatically signing in users. I can imagine, though, that this would be problematic to do, just like you can't remove badges from unworthy editors.