User blog comment:Tildeman123/A tutorial on how not to hate UCP/@comment-27831991-20200926171513

Dude, you have a big problem with your tutorial: just because we adapt to UCP doesn't mean we can't hate UCP. That's pretty much the biggest argument anyone can throw around. Other things...


 * You are forgetting that some wikis and users rely on Chat (and Forums). Unfortunately, saying "people can't get Discord or Slack easily" won't do squat, so let's just put in it short: wikis that rely on Chat (and Forums) are devastated.
 * The reason why Forums is so beloved is that it is simple to navigate and I don't think people will be fazed by accidentally picking the wrong categories and the design. Discussions, as far as my eye can see:
 * Require scrolling down a LOOOOOOOOOOOOONG mile if you just wanna find a Discussions Post that you really like.
 * For Legacy wikis, you can't see it on WIki Activity which makes moderation way harder than usual.
 * The Bell can't filter things through.
 * Cannot use wikitext at all.
 * No quoting which forces you to copy-paste the message you want to replace to and stuff like that.